This list of books with critiques started off as a segment picked up from an autism discussion list. I believe that it was compiled by an ASA chapter to be made available to Parents. Since, I wanted a page of book references, I thought this was a good place to start.
I'd like to expand this list and I'd like to include critiques. There are other lists, but it seems there aren't too many that really get into what the book is about. My goal is to provide more than just a list, but more a list with a brief critique of the book.
What I'm looking for in the critique is a breif description of the true subject matter of the book, how easy it was for you to understand the subject, and who you may feel it's geared to.
I also ask that they be kept as brief as possible, about 2 or 3 sentences if possible.
I will not add critiques that express your views on the subject matter. The idea is to present possibilities and let the readers decide if it's appropriate for their situation. I AM LOUDLY OPPOSED TO USING ANY FORUM OR FACILITY TO PUSH TECHNIQUES TO THE EXCLUSIONS OF OTHERS. I am a firm believer that many techniques and methods are good for some kids and not good for others. So I feel that what works for you may or may not work with someone else, it doesn't mean the technique is bad, it means that your kid learns differently.
As an example, if a book was about ABA, I'd rather hear what the author covers in the book, how clear it is and how easy it was for you to read and understand, if the book gave instructions or if it was just a discussion of a theory. This to me is much more constructive than a critique condemning the technique or subject. If the book is poor reading that's one thing, if you disagree with what is being taught that is quite a different thing.
Many people may look to this list as being a source of information, to find a book to tell them what ABA is for instance, not why it's good or bad.
In light of that, if you wish to suggest or critique a book please send your critique to me rjkopp@syr.edu.